Donate to help run the site
and get a custom "Supporting Member" forum member title.
Welcome to Studentfilms.com, the online film discussion forum for filmmakers and students who are applying to film school,
attending film school, need advice on making films, or just want to share their films with the world.
Hey guys awesome thread, I just found this site and its pretty epic. I just visited Columbia and NYU as well... must say NYU
was at my top before and now Columbia took its place.
I am applying for the Screenwriting/Directing program for Fall
2011 as well and was a little confused about the application but thanks to you I understood they haven't released any info.
A little about me My name is Paula and I am currently finishing my BA at Full Sail... 21 years old and god do I want
to get in Columbia.
Keep posting how everything goes, it is really interesting to know more people who are going through
the process.
Keep up the good work and the good energy!
Posts: 46 | Location: Orlando | Registered: September 13, 2010
Finished up at Columbia a couple of hours ago. It was a great visit and very informative. I spent about 40 minutes with
a 2nd year student discussing the overall minutiae of classes/housing/learning objectives and the like. Then i spoke with
an admissions officer (who is a recent film studies grad) for about 30 minutes discussing the application and his experiences
in the program.
The campus is beautiful and I ate lunch on the library steps while watching a crew of students do some
filming. I spoke to one of them briefly and she was very friendly.
I have not seen NYU yet, but it would have to be
pretty impressive to top Columbia. Definitely my first choice!
Post about nyu later in the weekend because i fly back
home right after the visit.
MAlbie
"Buy the premise, buy the bit" - Johnny Carson
Posts: 67 | Location: North Carolina | Registered: July 15, 2010
Malbie- glad you liked it! I'm a first year at Columbia (I was on campus from 8:30am to 9:30pm today!). I'm sure most of your
questions were answered today, but feel free to ask me if you have any more!
Posts: 306 | Location: New York City | Registered: June 06, 2009
I was there from 10:00 until 12. Every time I saw the students
I kept wondering "Is that someone from the forum?"
I meant to post a mini-note about NYU the day after I returned
but my MBA program swallowed my free time and I am only now coming up for air. So here we go:
I spent about an hour
and half with NYU admissions officer and had a fantastic time. We went through the entire program from application to graduation.
He answered all of my questions and extremely helpful on solving a couple of nagging issues I had. We spent the last 20 minutes
talking about upcoming movies and films that we had recently seen.
Then he wrote me a note that allowed me to go across
the street and visit the school itself. I spent about an hour roaming the halls and talking with students, but unfortunately
did not get to speak with any faculty or staff. I was impressed by the facilities and the caliber of the students.
So
impressed in fact that I now am back to square one. I was torn between NYU and Columbia before I went up there and as I posted
earlier, I felt like Columbia was my first choice after that visit. But now that I have seen NYU and spoken to the students
I must say that I do not have a favorite.
While they are very different schools with very different philosophies,
they both appeal to me. So I have decided to apply to Columbia for the Film MFA and to NYU for the Dramatic Writing.
I will concentrate on screenwriting regardless of the school.
A couple of notes for future readers:
1: Make
an appointment before you visit and arrive an hour or so early. I was able to walk around both campuses and get a feel for
the school. At Columbia I was even able to watch some students filming a scene on the steps, which was a great experience.
2: Take a digital recorder with you to record your meeting. I use a Sandisk Sanza Fuze MP3 player which has a microphone
and outputs to MP3. I was able to record all of the conversations at both schools instead of having to write them done. It
let me give the person my full attention and now I have the recordings on my hard drive to make sure I didn't miss anything.
Just ask the person before you record.
3: Remember to thank whoever you speak with for their time and to send a
Thank You email/note.
4: Come with a list of questions already made out and organized.
Alright that is
it for now. I did my NYU application this morning and its 90% complete (still tweaking my Personal Statement). Waiting patiently
for Columbia to open theirs up in October.
"Buy the premise, buy the bit" - Johnny Carson
Posts: 67 | Location: North Carolina | Registered: July 15, 2010
I'm applying to Columbia and possibly NYU as well. I'm also 35(!) and studied business undergrad, an underwhelming
experience at best.
I was just going to be the old lurker in the shadows, but you really inspired me to speak up.
After
working in media for over 10 years, 5 in television as a news writer and producer...I've decided to go to film school. I'm
working on my applications now, and I wish I was 90 percent complete. It's a lot on the old ticker.
Best of luck!
Posts: 11 | Location: New York | Registered: September 29, 2010
Welcome to the board Iboogs and I wish you good luck.
I know that Columbia has at least one student over 40 and that
NYU has one over 50 (or maybe I have those reversed) but either way we are both younger than at least two current students.
Groovydazzle
- Neither of the two main New York schools requires the GRE for their primary programs. I think the Film Studies at NYU (and
maybe their dual MBA/MFA program) require the GRE, but the directing/writing/producing track does not seem to.
"Buy the premise, buy the bit" - Johnny Carson
Posts: 67 | Location: North Carolina | Registered: July 15, 2010
This may sound like a ridiculous question, but I'm wondering if anyone could guide me to the application. I'd like to apply
for the MFA program but all the paperwork and online app seems to be for 2010. Any ideas???
Posts: 151 | Location: Solaris | Registered: September 17, 2010
Yeah, I don't think the 2011 application becomes available until the end of October. But usually the only thing that changes
are the story prompts. They just did a complete overhaul of the School of the Arts website that went live today, so maybe
they have the application up now...I haven't gone and looked at the new page yet.
MAlbie - both Columbia and NYU are
great programs, as I'm sure you know. They are somewhat different though. I'm not sure how the dramatic writing program differs
from the rest of the school, but from what I understand, NYU is a lot more technical with their instruction (which is why
so many great DP's come out of NYU). Columbia's curriculum, on the other hand, is entirely based around the story. Even the
directing classes emphasize using your direction to serve the story. Everyone writes at least one feature film.
You
probably already know this, but it's worth repeating for people who won't have a chance to visit before hand: Everyone at
Columbia has the same first year, so everyone tries directing, everyone tries writing, and everyone tries producing. If you
entered as a writing/directing concentrate, you have until the end of the first year to pick your concentration (writing or
directing, though you can cross over some classes).
I'm sure this can be said at any of the top film schools, but
there is a lot lot lot lot of work. I'm sure you can relate since you're getting your MBA, but it's a huge test of your time
management skills.
Posts: 306 | Location: New York City | Registered: June 06, 2009
Yeah, they said it was going live tonight and it would take them a week or so to work out all the glitches. I've noticed a
few myself, but so far the new website is much easier to navigate.
Posts: 306 | Location: New York City | Registered: June 06, 2009
Hi everyone, I found this awesome forum since last year and applied for 2010 fall producing program(ended up admitted by
FSU, waitlist of Columbia and rejected by USC,ucla,NYU,AFI.) After finishing an indie feature, I'm going to reapply to
Columbia and USC this year. I've emailed to both offices of admission, asking about some reapplication details, but got no
response so far...
Posts: 15 | Location: Taiwan | Registered: February 21, 2010
Hey guys ! This is an awesome thread ..cleared a whole lot of my doubts .... Well i still had some doubts unclear....
my
background: I am chaitanya, a second year, Mass Media student from Mumbai,India.
my problem: I am keen on doing a
Masters in this genre... but i am confused over Production,cinematography and editing. As a part of my Undergrad course..
i have done direction, cinematography and editing but i really figure out what i want to do .....so i'd appreciate it if you
could help me out with colleges.
I have been through the USC production site, however i could not find out the tuition
fees and the average cost of living in big cities like NY or LA.
Thanks for reading my post and i want to thank all
of you for your posts and replies....
Posts: 6 | Location: Mumbai | Registered: October 26, 2010