• Before you can add your own film to the site you will need to be a contributing member of our filmmaking community.

    Join the site to remove ads and read more about How to Submit Film.

Latest reviews

Latest Most helpful Rating
F
A KNOCK FROM COLD FINGERS

A KNOCK FROM COLD FINGERS

Blackknight2421
Intriguing and spooky!
Pros: I really enjoyed the shot where you could see the lights in the pitch black room when the main character returns from checking outside - Overall great production, writing, suspense, and tension building.
Cons: Could use more interesting/creative shots, could use a bit more colour contrast and music contrast, and may benefit from a more blended vocal audio so the main character sounds more natural.
This was really inspiring to watch. I can tell you put a lot of effort into the editing and production of this piece - it feels very well done. This short film excites me because I can tell you'd be able to apply your skills well with a larger story/world to build on. Overall a nice job, hope my feedback can be helpful.
Bad_UpKeep
CROCODILE NIGHTS 001

CROCODILE NIGHTS 001

marikhbattlecry
Strong Setup, Softer Payoff
Pros: > Suspenseful art moments.
> Effective use of POV style enhances immersion
> Strong atmospheric tension and mood
> Creative concept that keeps viewers engaged.
Cons: >Technical elements (like camera movement/shot clarity) could be tighter
> Some pacing feels uneven (A few moments were cringy and too long.)
> Fight scene lacked conviction.
MALAM BUAYA 001 commits fully to its POV horror approach, and the absence of dialogue places strong emphasis on visual storytelling and atmosphere. The first-person perspective creates immediacy and pulls the viewer directly into the experience, allowing tension to build through framing, pacing, and sound rather than exposition. The confined setting and steady progression toward the final scene effectively establish a sense of unease.*

The central attack sequence, however, could benefit from more intensity and sharper physical choreography to strengthen the realism and perceived stakes of the confrontation. In the closing scene, as the restrained victim watches the killer sharpen tools, the visual tension is strong, but the extended vocal reactions feel slightly overstated. A more restrained performance or subtler sound design might enhance the psychological dread and make the ending even more unsettling.

BadUpKeepLogo.png
  • Like
Reactions: marikhbattlecry
Bad_UpKeep
COLOURS

COLOURS

Mill Francis
Emotionally Impactful but Stylistically Uneven
Pros: >Meaningful, thoughtful message on mental health.
>Strong emotional engagement.
Cons: >The film relies heavily on continuous panning between characters during dialogue scenes rather than cutting between shots, which occasionally slows the pacing.
> At times, uncontrolled ambient sound in select locations compromised dialogue intelligibility and weakened the overall sound mix.
COLOURS is a compelling student short film that tackles the delicate topic of mental awareness with sensitivity and emotional clarity. The film blends powerful visuals with a thoughtful narrative that resonates long after watching. As a short format piece, it uses its runtime effectively to highlight key moments and provoke reflection. The performances feel genuine, and the direction shows promise. There are a few moments where I wished certain themes had more time to develop, but overall the film delivers a strong message in a compact, impactful package. It’s a poignant example of what student filmmakers can achieve when addressing important real-world topics.

BadUpKeep_combined_transparent_tight_logo.png
MD1NIne
Littering Short Film

Littering Short Film

Jobydobey
Good night, and Good Luck
Pros: Poignant subject matter, clever interpretation of social issues told through character POV, nice sound design & editing in places
Cons: Bumps in sound or story that were a little distracting, titles at the end seem generic, and a little hard to read.
A once carefree childhood is fondly remembered by a young man who deals with the daily challenges of the world. He struggles with socioenvironmental factors that eventually cause him to become an agent of change to overcome his emotional and mental obstacles. Visually and musically interesting but occasionally stalling, the end titles could be highlighted more in the end, where the message would have landed a bit more solidly.
Back
Top